South African court dismisses Nigerian’s N430m suit over 117-day detention

A South African appellate court has thrown out a Nigerian man's bid to obtain about N430m in compensation over his 117-day detention following his arrest in connection with the discovery of a man's body in a room he rented in Durban.

The Supreme Court of Appeal dismissed Sunday Okoro's application seeking a review of an earlier decision that denied him permission to challenge the rejection of his damages claim against the Minister of Police.

According to South African news platform, IOL, the legal battle stemmed from Okoro's arrest on July 3, 2002, after police officers discovered a man hanging by a bedsheet in the shower of room seven at Evaleigh Court, an apartment Okoro had reportedly rented days earlier.

Okoro was held in custody for nearly four months before prosecutors withdrew the murder charges against him on November 29, 2002.

Following his release, he instituted a legal action against the police minister, demanding R5.41m in damages, estimated at approximately N430m, over what he described as wrongful arrest and prolonged detention.

However, the KwaZulu-Natal High Court in Durban rejected his claim and ordered him to pay the legal costs, holding that the police had sufficient grounds to suspect him of involvement in the alleged murder.

Dissatisfied with the decision, Okoro sought permission to appeal but was unsuccessful at both the High Court and the Supreme Court of Appeal. He subsequently approached the president of the appellate court to reconsider the refusal.

The application was considered by a three-member panel comprising Acting Judges of Appeal Mjali and Molitsoane, alongside Judge of Appeal Nicholls.

In its decision, the majority, made up of Molitsoane and Nicholls, rejected Okoro's request and awarded costs against him.

The court heard that two police officers, Warrant Officer Allen Mark Naidu and Warrant Officer Sunil Seosunker, were on crime-prevention patrol in Durban's Point area when they encountered Okoro near the apartment building.

According to evidence presented in court, Okoro reportedly entered the building after noticing the police vehicle, prompting the officers to follow him.

Naidu told the court that he later saw Okoro emerging from room seven in an agitated condition and repeatedly calling out the name Francine.

The officer said Okoro invited them into the room, where they found the deceased hanging in the shower. The man's body was reportedly cold and stiff, with no detectable pulse.

Naidu testified that he suspected the scene might have been arranged to make a murder appear like suicide, particularly because the position of the deceased's feet did not suggest that he had used the shower ledge to hang himself.

The appellate court also found no evidence that the police had deliberately withheld relevant information, misled prosecutors or manipulated the circumstances to keep Okoro in detention.

It consequently upheld the position that there was no legal basis to hold the police minister responsible for Okoro's continued detention after his initial appearance in court.

Previous Post Next Post
📢
JOIN OUR NEWS UPDATES GROUP Get the latest news and important updates directly on WhatsApp.
JOIN NOW
Submit

Submit

Submit

نموذج الاتصال